Disposable non-woven fabric vs biodegradable non-woven fabric: who is more environmentally friendly? Comprehensive Comparison and Selection Guide
2025-04-03

With the tightening of environmental policies and the awakening of consumers' green awareness, flushable and biodegradable non-woven fabrics have become popular alternative solutions. But who is more environmentally friendly between the two? This article provides in-depth analysis from four dimensions: material composition, decomposition mechanism, application scenarios, and ecological impact, to help you make scientific choices.


1、 Definition and core differences

Disposable non-woven fabric
Material: It is usually composed of short fibers such as wood pulp and viscose fibers, reinforced by water jet technology.
Standard: Must comply with the international INDA/EDANA "washability guidelines" (such as 7-day decomposition rate ≥ 95%).

Features: Quickly disperses when in contact with water, claims to be safe to flush into the toilet, commonly seen in wet wipes and hygiene products.


Degradable non-woven fabric
Materials: PLA (polylactic acid), PBAT (biobased polyester), or natural fiber blends are commonly used.
Standard: Must comply with ISO 13432 (compostable certification) and decompose over 90% in 180 days under industrial composting conditions.

Characteristics: It relies on microbial action to decompose into water, carbon dioxide, and biomass, and is suitable for packaging, agriculture, and other fields.


2、 Comparison of Environmental Performance

Dimension
Disposable Non woven Fabric
Degradable Non woven Fabric
Decomposition conditions
water flow+pipeline mechanical force (simulating toilet environment)
high temperature/high humidity industrial composting environment required
Decomposition products
microfiber fragments (possible residue)
CO ₂, water, organic matter (completely decomposed)
Ecological risk
possible blockage of pipelines or entry into water bodies
slow degradation in ordinary environments, requiring classified recycling
Carbon footprint
low (mainly wood pulp)
high (high energy consumption in PLA production)


3、 Suggested application scenarios

Choose washable non-woven fabric:
✅  Disposable items that require immediate handling (such as mother and baby wipes, portable sanitary napkins)
✅  Areas with well-developed sewage treatment systems (such as some cities in Europe and America)
❌  Avoid using for old pipelines or septic tank systems
Choose biodegradable non-woven fabric:
✅  Scenarios for recyclable compost (supermarket shopping bags, agricultural film)
✅  Policy mandates compostable areas (such as the EU single use plastic ban)

❌  Avoid using in areas without supporting composting facilities


4、 Industry Trends and Innovation Directions

Policy driven:
The EU Directive on Disposable Plastics requires all packaging materials to be recyclable or compostable by 2030.

China's "plastic ban order" promotes an annual increase of 25% in PLA non-woven fabric production capacity.


Technological breakthrough:
Dual mode decomposition materials: Some companies have developed washable and compostable non-woven fabrics (such as wood pulp+PLA blends).

Enzymatic degradation technology: adding biological enzymes to accelerate the degradation rate in ordinary environments.


conclusion

The environmental friendliness of washable and biodegradable non-woven fabrics is not absolute and needs to be comprehensively evaluated in combination with usage scenarios and infrastructure. In the short term, dispersible products have an advantage in convenience; In the long run, biodegradable materials are more in line with the trend of circular economy.